Was John Really A Bad King Essay

634 Words3 Pages
Was John really a bad king? Through out history King John has been portrayed as a villainous king for example in the legends of Robin Hood he is shown as a greedy and cruel ruler who treated his people unfairly. However this may not be an accurate picture of him as for example he fed hundreds of paupers on feast days and he was hard working, often travelling the country and sitting in on court cases. Many of the problems he faced in running the country were in fact caused by Richard 1 who had neglected England. Sources from the time of John describe John as a poor leader and that he was greedy for money. For example Mathew Paris who was a monk living near London writes, “John lost Normandy and many other lands because of his own laziness.…show more content…
Records show that he did tax the people heavily. He frequently quarrelled with the church and seized much of the churches property in England. During his reign John upset the barons causing them to eventually rebel against him and he was forced to agree to change the way he ran the country. This became known as the Magna Carta. There were also reports that John severely punished his enemies and used the courts to help his friends. He was also accused of killing his own nephew Arthur because he was a rival to his throne. Most of these reports on John were written by monks and these were unreliable because John had quarrelled with their leader the Pope. This meant only a few monks were unbiased and wrote truthfully about John. For example another source this time written by a monk in Barnwell said that John was a good ruler and that his own men should not have deserted him. This monk was known for not letting his feelings influence his writing about a person and so this might be a more accurate picture of John. Medieval records seem to show him as hard working because of the way he travelled the country sitting in on courts. John also increased the size of his navy. He also had a small library carried around with him when ever he travelled. Books were rare at the time which might suggest that he was an intelligent
Open Document