Relevant, Reliable, and Competent

526 Words3 Pages
Relevant, Reliable, and Competent Ashley Cooper October 26, 2013 Criminal Evidence For this assignment, provide definitions for these three qualities of evidence. Additionally, find a criminal court case that contains an example of relevant, reliable or competent evidence. You can use findlaw.com or other search engines to locate a useful case. What are the basic facts of the case? What is the evidence that is relevant, reliable or competent? Explain your answers using the court’s opinion or your own analysis. There are three things lawyers find themselves debating on in any case just about and they are relevance, reliable and competent evidence. Relevance means having direct bearing on the matter in hand and a connection to the subject or the issue. Reliable is when a witness or any sort of suspect is worthy of reliance, trust, belief, and dependable. Competent evidence means legally admissible evidence. Competent evidence tends to prove the matter in dispute. In a murder trial, for example, competent evidence might include the murder weapon with the defendant's fingerprints on it. (http://www.nolo.com/dictionary/competent-evidence-term.html.) A case that has all three qualities of these are Arthur BROWN, Jr., Petitioner–Appellant, v. Rick THALER, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Respondent–Appellee. No. 11–70012-- June 12, 2012. Where he evening, six people were bound and shot in the head at Rachel Tovar's residence in Houston. Four of them died, one being a nine month’s pregnant teenager. The reliable in this case are Rachel Tovar and Alexander Camarillo, also known as Nicolas Cortez Anzures, survived and testified at Brown's trial and they new Brown and his accomplice, Dudley from previous drug deals and was identified as the shooters. Competent Evidence in this case is that Brown had bought some

More about Relevant, Reliable, and Competent

Open Document