Reading Schemes and "Real" Books in the Teaching of Reading

1646 Words7 Pages
Critically evaluate the contribution that reading scheme materials and “real books” can make to the teaching of reading. Children need many opportunities for reading everyday, both individually and silently, and in groups with other children and adults. A child's goal in learning to read, is not only to be able to do it but also to enjoy themselves in doing so. The choice in books must be carefully selected, but whether the choice between “real books” and reading schemes are necessary will be discussed here. This essay will explore the strengths and weaknesses of using either reading schemes or “real books” in a teaching environment. The ongoing books-or-schemes debate categorizes reading materials for children to base their reading improvement with either reading schemes or “real books.” Reading schemes are an assessed and progressive series of books, that aid in demonstrating the level of children's reading ability. Typically numbered, children can identify their progress by the book cover (Meek 1984: 67). “Real books” are almost any other children's book that may or may not be aimed at specific age groups. The BBC (2002), and other sources have stated that teaching children to read from “real books” is more beneficial than reading schemes. The debate between these materials of teaching reading has seen many advantages and disadvantages on both sides. Reading schemes provide children with many benefits in their development of reading. These teaching materials provide a reliable and acceptable proof of progression of the child's reading (Harrison, 1998). This progression aids the children to improve their skills and comprehension steadily with a wide variety of texts at each level. An example of reading schemes books includes the Oxford Reading Tree books, which aim to provide children with a variety of different book series that individually teach children phonics
Open Document