Trouble With Self Esteem: Lauren Slater's Trouble With Self-Esteem

827 Words4 Pages
Laureano, Manuel Instructor: Vergara C. ENC1102 Words: 783 November 18, 2012 “Trouble With Self-Esteem: Lauren Slater’s Outlook” This essay will explain how Slater attempts to rethink and refute the social concept of self-esteem, in regards to her essay “Trouble with Self-Esteem’. In order to do this, the ideas Slater uses to persuade her audience to give up the long-held belief that self-esteem is positive in society will be discussed. Self-Esteem is something that all humans must deal with at one time or another. For a long time people believed that self-esteem is directly linked to whether or not you will live a positive life. In Lauren Slater’s essay “Trouble with Self-Esteem” she believes that the popular view of…show more content…
Our society views high self-esteem as a good thing. Cockiness and smugness are considered healthy practices of good self-esteem. Lauren Slater believes that low self-esteem should not be associated with bad outcomes in life, nor should it be considered a cause of poor performance. Nicholas Emler of the London School of Economics is one of the people that Lauren Slater consulted with. In “Trouble with Self-Esteem” Nicholas Emler states ''There is absolutely no evidence that low self-esteem is particularly harmful”. ''It's not at all a cause of poor academic performance; people with low self-esteem seem to do just as well in life as people with high self-esteem. In fact, they may do better, because they often try harder.''(Slater 859) Lauren Slater uses not only personal evidence to make her case but she also finds other credible people to provide more information toward her…show more content…
Lauren Slater states ''The fact is,'' Emler says, ''we've put antisocial men through every self-esteem test we have, and there's no evidence for the old psychodynamic concept that they secretly feel bad about themselves. These men are racist or violent because they don't feel bad enough about themselves.''(Slater 860) Lauren Slater also met with Roy Baumeister of Case Western Reserve University. Essentially, Roy believes that the unexpected notion that self-esteem is overrated and to suggest that it may even is a culprit, not a cure. In Lauren Slater’s “Trouble with Self-Esteem” Baumeister and his colleagues write: ''People who believe themselves to be among the top 10 percent on any dimension may be insulted and threatened whenever anyone asserts that they are in the 80th or 50th or 25th percentile. In contrast, someone with lower self-esteem who regards himself or herself as being merely in the top 60 percent would only be threatened by the feedback that puts him or her at the 25th percentile. . . . In short, the more favorable one's view of oneself, the greater the range of external feedback that will be perceived as unacceptably low.''(Slater
Open Document