The Puritan Dilemma Summary

2276 Words10 Pages
The Puritans: Were they successful in creating their vision of ‘a City upon a Hill? Physical separation from the Anglican Church was the first step the Puritans took in breathing life into their vision for the New World. They felt as though the Bible was the ultimate book of instructions for an individual to live a pure, Christian lifestyle. The Puritans were successful in creating a prosperous colony that flourished socially and economically. However, Native American bloodshed, their harsh persecution of religious dissenters, and the Salem Witch trials are a blatant display of their hypocritical ways. The Puritans were contradictory in nature, and ultimately they fell short in meeting their goal of constructing the perfect Christian society.…show more content…
“[The church] should be purified of their unregenerate members…heretical clergymen…bishops and archbishops, but they were nevertheless churches and must be embraced as churches” (Morgan 31). These non-separating Puritans made it their goal to create a superlative Christian community in the New World. In doing so they hoped to serve as an example to encourage reform within the Church of England. Morgan, author of The Puritan Dilemma, describes the non-separating Puritans overall view of the Church of England to be more positive than negative. “[The church] had bought the means of salvation to many of their members and might still do so” (Morgan 31). Amongst these Puritans who believed that the church was in desperate need to reform was John Winthrop—a wealthy Puritan…show more content…
Winthrop formed the Massachusetts Bay joint stock company and governed the colony. For those seeking change from corrupt England, this charter became a chance to establish a “true Christian commonwealth” (Breen 35). They sought to create a society where “the will of God would be observed in every detail” (Morgan 69) because they felt as though England failed them by deviating from Gods’ word. Ultimately the Puritans wanted to emphasize that the Bible was the supreme law of the land as well as the only source of instructions to live by as a Christian. They wanted to establish the New World as a region free of sin. From 1630 to 1640, more than 20,000 colonists boarded the Arabella with their families and made their way to the New World from England. This became known as the Great Migration. With the colonization of the Massachusetts Bay area, Winthrop’s a city upon a hill concept began to come
Open Document