Incarceration And Reproductive Oppression Analysis

2097 Words9 Pages
Genetics and Ethics, SCCL 6305 16 February 2011 Incarceration and Reproductive Oppression Our soul speaks to us in the way a compass points us in the right direction. Its words reverberate in our consciousness calling us to our deepest aspirations. Justice, freedom, love, compassion – the words all articulate an internal desire. If we listen closely, we find we are attracted to the one we desire the most. And for women, that desire is often freedom: the freedom to allow their bodies to speak. The founder of Planned Parenthood, Margaret Singer explains: ” No woman can call herself free who does not own and control her own body. No woman can call herself free until she can choose consciously whether she will or will not be a mother”…show more content…
Long-acting contraceptives like Norplant have been ordered for women convicted of child abuse which does nothing to treat the abuser’s psychological tendencies. Norplant is a controversial method of birth control that became available in 1991 from the FDA. This drug consists of six matchstick-size silicone capsules which are inserted in a woman’s upper arm. Although Norplant has serious side effects such as headaches and irregular bleeding, it is extremely effective. Unfortunately, it has been widely used as an infringement on the reproductive autonomy of convicted women. In several cases, judges have given women convicted of child abuse or drug use during pregnancy a “choice” between using Norplant or serving time in jail. While a woman’s use of Norplant prevents conception, it does not stop her from taking drugs or abusing her children. The solution to this complex problem involves psychological assessments and adequate drug rehabilitation, not punishment. Using Norplant as a condition of sentencing is wrong. Since this drug is often mandated for low income women or women of color, the policy of forced sterilization is reminiscent of the oppressive eugenics movement which sought to reduce the size of the underclass. Norplant was developed to improve reproductive freedom, not restrict…show more content…
After volunteering for Resolana, a nonprofit organization that provides holistic, gender-sensitive, rehabilitative programming for incarcerated women, I would emphatically disagree. While it is easy on the outside to look upon convicted women with discriminatory scorn, it takes only an open heart and an open mind to understand the struggles of the women in stripes. Few incarcerated women have committed violent offenses; their primary pathway to incarceration is substance abuse. Poverty, trauma, mental health issues and addiction are interrelated problems in their lives and these problems are often exacerbated by their incarceration. But in a correctional system designed for and dominated by men, women remain an underserved

More about Incarceration And Reproductive Oppression Analysis

Open Document