Pros And Cons Of Pregnant Addicts

2296 Words10 Pages
Pregnant Addicts: The Best Outcome for Mother and Child Kimberly Brooks Ottawa University OAD 40654 Health Care Law and Ethics January 15, 2013 Richard Hardy Pregnant Addicts: The Best Outcome for Mother and Child Introduction Illegal drugs and/or alcohol used by addicted women during pregnancy pose a significant health problem. Since the 1970’s prosecutors have made the use of illegal drugs a complex legal question. They have included criminal child abuse, criminal child mistreatment and attempted to charge mother’s with attempted first degree murder or even intentional homicide when the fetus or child does not live. State appellate courts have almost uniformly found criminal prosecution…show more content…
If cocaine was found to be present the woman were jailed before or after their pregnancy. The courts charged these woman with child abuse. Criminal decisions are without substantial input from experts (Schroedel, 2001). The women that did challenge these charges had their cases overturned at the appellate level. The appellate court found that the women were denied due process and their rights according to the 14th amendment were impeded on. This program denied these woman accesses to alternatives that may have helped them succeed. If they were imprisoned they did not receive adequate prenatal care in the prison and further the availability of drugs in prison was not beneficial (Paltrow, 2001). This practice of testing suspected drug abuse pregnant women was investigated and the National Institute of Health investigation found this practice violated federal regulations to protect human subjects of research. The office of civil rights and the hospital came to an agreement and the testing…show more content…
• Utilize existing funds for the prevention and treatment of alcoholism and drug dependency among women and their families. • Review agency services, and propose the coordination of related programs between alcohol and drug treatment, social services, education, and the maternal health and child care field in order to improve maternal and child health. (Paltrow, n.d.) Leading public health organizations, including the American Medical Association (AMA), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP),American Nurses Association, American Society of Addiction Medicine,National Association for Perinatal Addiction Research andEducation, National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence, and American Public Health Association, oppose the prosecution of pregnant women who use drugs. These groups recognize that such an approach undermines maternal and fetal health because the threat of criminal charges and the fear of losing their children deter women from seeking prenatal care and drug treatment (Paltrow, 2001) Barriers to a Caring
Open Document