Commentary on an extract of Othello by Shakespeare

966 Words4 Pages
In this extract Barbantio accuses Othello in front of the duke and a senator of poisoning and kidnapping his daughter. This is a very important part of the play as it’s the first time Desdemona’s love towards Othello is questioned. Barbantio makes Othello seem as a thief because he can’t believe Desdemona would ever fall in love with a black person. The senator and the duke do not believe this as they think there is no evidence that makes the story true: “To vouch this is no proof”.

Othello uses persuasive language to make the others understand that he is telling the truth about their mutual love. He uses lots of adjectives in front of words that don’t need them to contribute towards his persuasion such as “very noble”, “good masters” “gracious patience” or “dearest action”. He does this firstly to show respect towards the senator and duke and secondly for him not to be judged as a bad person and gain their trust. One of his first arguments was that all his life he has been warrior, not a witch; that all his knowledge is about war. He makes this point by saying “And little of this world can I speak more than pertains to feats of broil and battle” This makes the senator and the duke double think Barbantio’s accusations. Othello’s tone in all his speech is calm as he knows he is saying the truth. This way of speaking makes his side of the story more believable for the senator and the duke as it creates an effect of certainty and knowledge of the situation. Othello uses phrases to create an effect of pity on him such as “That I have ta’en away this old man’s daughter it is most true; true, I have married her” Which means that he has taken her daughter, but not by kidnapping which implies violence, but by marriage which implies love towards each other and compromise. Also by saying “I won his daughter” he makes it clear that it took a lot of effort
Open Document