‘the Magisterium Is Out of Touch with the Lives of Modern Catholics.’

366 Words2 Pages
‘The Magisterium is out of touch with the lives of modern Catholics.’ I disagree with this statement; firstly because the whole point of the Magisterium is to ensure that the teachings of the church are updated, therefore meaning that they are always correct. Without them the Church’s teachings would be irrelevant, thus meaning they must be in touch with the lives of modern Catholic’s in order to interpret the Bible for them. Secondly, the Magisterium provides set of clear guidelines for Catholics on how to behave and what to believe. How would they be able to deem what is right, and wrong if they were out of touch with today’s society, and problems. Thirdly, they can address issues that did not exist in the time of the Apostles. This is important as Catholics can’t find these problems in the Bible. In order to be able to do this, they must keep up to date with the lives of today’s Catholics. On the other hand people may disagree with me, firstly because in order to become part of the Magisterium, you must first be a bishop. It takes a long time in the Catholic Church in order to become a bishop, in turn a member of the Magisterium. Therefore how they are able to keep up with the lives of modern Catholic’s if they are not part of their “generation”. Secondly, people may argue that once you become a member of the Magisterium, you live a very sheltered life, as a place to live in the Vatican is also given to them with the job. This can mean that due to the fact that they no longer live out with the rest of society, they are no longer able to relate to people’s struggles, and are no longer able to keep in touch with today’s Catholics. Finally, some could argue that the Church still has a very old fashioned view on some of today’s issues such as; Gay Marriage and Abortion. Therefore they are not keeping up with today’s society. The world around us is changing every
Open Document