The Comparisons and the Contrasts of the Crucible

1326 Words6 Pages
The Comparisons and the Contrasts of The Crucible Thesis: Arthur Miller uses both similarities and differences in both the film and the play, The Crucible. In my opinion the play is the better out of the two. I. The play and the film of The Crucible A. Similarities between the film and the play. B. The differences in the film. C. The differences in the play. D. In the play and the film of The Crucible, the added scenes in the film help to Understand the play in ways that reading it alone could not. II. The Similarities in both the Film and Play. A. In Both the Play and the film the similarities are quite obvious. B. Some Similarities are that in both the play and film is that John Proctor and Abigail Williams had an affair. This is mentioned when Abigail says “Give me a word, John. A soft word.” (Act One: line 406). C. Another Similarity is that Abigail and the other young town girls go and dance in the woods. This is mentioned when Parris asks Abigail, “What did you do with her in the forest?” III. Differences in the Film A. The film adds scenes that were not in the play, like the scene where John Proctor and Abigail Williams meet in the woods after he hears that Elizabeth is mentioned in the court. In the play this scene never occurred. (Act one). B. Another scene that is added is that of when Abigail decides to run away with Mercy Lewis, in the film Abigail goes to the jail where John is being held and she tells John that she is going to Barbados. Only in the play Abigail just disappears from the story just to be brought up by Parris when he says to Judge Hathrone. Parris says to Hathrone, “My niece, sir, my niece- I believe she has vanished.”(Act Four; lines140-41). C. The added scenes help the audience to make connections between the film and the play. The added scenes add the in between that the play does not. IV. Differences

More about The Comparisons and the Contrasts of the Crucible

Open Document