Study Sources G, H and I. How Far Do These Sources Suggest the Smaller Monasteries Were Dissolved in 1536 Because of Their Corruption?

639 Words3 Pages
Study sources G, H and I. How far do these sources suggest the smaller monasteries were dissolved in 1536 because of their corruption? Sources G and H do support the argument suggesting that the smaller monasteries were dissolved in 1536 due to proof of their corruption. However Source I follows the argument that the monasteries were not corrupt and were only dissolved due to their financial benefits to King Henry VIII. Source G suggests that the monasteries wrongly abused their influential power over the common folk, gaining money from the supposed religious relics they claimed to be in ownership of. Items such as ‘God’s coat, Our Lady’s smock’ and ‘part of God’s supper,’ this implies corruption because deception was being used against the ordinary worshippers. Source G also suggests that corruption was held amongst monks, telling us of their illegitimate children under their supposed life of celibacy and the holy fathers inability to life such a life ‘The Pope, considering this holy father’s weakness, has given him license to keep a whore.’ Source G is a report given by Richard Layton to Cromwell in 1535, providing Cromwell with ammunition for the Valor Ecclesiasticus. Source H is similar to Source G suggesting that there was corruption in the monasteries, stating that the monasteries live in ‘Manifest sin, vicious, carnal and abominable living.’ The source also states that such doing is on the increase ‘their vicious living shamelessly increases’ suggesting that the only way in order to stop such doings, was to dissolve the monasteries. Source H confirms the points made in Source G, suggesting corruption was at the heart of royal motives for dissolution. However, both sources, although go very far in supporting the idea stated, their weight as evidence is limited by their reliability and context. Source G is heavily influenced by Cromwell’s evangelical want to
Open Document