Mary Anne Warren's Argumentative Analysis

1134 Words5 Pages
Abortion is a hot button topic in society and Mary Anne Warren has an interesting and controversial argument on the matter. Warren has what would be considered a politically liberal view on the matter. She feels a fetus has no inborn rights at conception. She feels that they lack traits that actually qualify them as a viable and living human being. She uses this argument as a way of attacking the pro life arguments about life as a human being beginning at conception. Warren uses the argument that the definition of the term human has two distinct definitions. The first definition that Warren has of what a human being is comes from the standards genetic meaning. That meaning is basically the textbook definition of what a human being…show more content…
In Warren's argument the ability to communicate is vital to being a human being. This is one where the fetus probably loses the most as they have no real means to communicate with the outside world. At best the argument can be made that their kicking is them trying to communicate. But this is another instance and probably the best one where it could be used to carry her position forward to the point of “aborting” people who are far beyond the womb. Let is take Doctor Steven Hawking for example. Remove him from a very specific and narrow envronment, in this case his wheelchair and the apparatus connected to it that detects his very limited movement and translates it to a computer that he uses to communicate, and he loses his status as a human being by the Warren argument. In this case one of the most brilliant men to ever live would be in line to be “aborted”. The final concept of the five is self awareness, which is very similar in definition to consciousness. In fact it is the definition of the word according to Miriam-Webster. To look at this one must expand the view of self awareness. This is a very vague concept and hard to really define. If it is just consciousness then the argument on the subject was made a few paragraphs ago. If i9t means when does one become aware one is a living being then it is also difficult to quantify as when does one gain the ability to communicate this and as communication is also a requirement what if one lacks that
Open Document