How Have the Marxist Notions of Class Been Challenged by Later Schools of Thought

2046 Words9 Pages
The notion of ‘class’ is one of the most controversial and constantly challenged categories of historical analysis applied in the writing of labour history. The Marxist theory of class, first based on the writings of Karl Marx, has been vastly influential in establishing an eminent definition of ‘class’ and ‘class formation’. However, historians who believe that Marx’s structural emphasis and economic determinism are not adequate alone to reflect the formation of class have consistently questioned the pre-eminence of ‘class’. For instance, E.P Thompson’s work, The Making of the English Working Class brought the cultural aspects of class to the fore. However, it is undeniable that Marxism has provided a vital and consistent explanation for how class came about. Karl Marx developed the first Marxist ideas of class, whilst studying British society during a time that was rife with industrial revolution and social change in the 1840’s. Marx idea of class was firmly based around production. He believed that the British society was divided into two classes, the bourgeoisie (capital owner) and the proletariat (worker), and therefore defined these classes regarding their relationship to the means of production. It became apparent to Marx that the gap was widening between the two classes, which was illustrated by the growing difference of living standards between the bourgeoisie and proletariat. This created a general rise in recognition of common interests within the proletariat regarding the contrast of the situations between the two classes, thus creating ‘class-consciousness,’ which Marx believed would inevitably result in conflicts between the classes and ‘class struggle.’ To orthodox Marxists, class and class formation is determined wholly by economics, and therefore is a ‘structuralist’ argument. Although the Marxist ideas of class have been commended for many
Open Document