How Far Do the Sources Agree That Cholera Epidemics Caused People to Question Public Health Provision in the 19th Century? (20)

1147 Words5 Pages
How far do the sources agree that cholera epidemics caused people to question public health provision in the 19th century? (20) At first glance the sources do not seem to go very far at all into showing that cholera caused people to question public health. Only one of the sources was actually written at the time. And not one of the sources clearly writes about people opinions about public health. However I know from my own knowledge that the 19th century was a time of massive heath reforms in Britton. With this in mind I can start to see different aspects of the three sources, which might make them agree that cholera epidemics cause people to question public heath. Source 13, does not agree or disagree with the question, which does not make the source very useful. However there is a small passage about the effect that Cholera had at the very end of the source, it does say that Cholera got “attention from everyone, from all shades and all forms of opinion.” I know that in the early 19th century the government relied on the middle class for money and votes to stay in parliament. So if people from “all shades” where suddenly worried about Cholera then the government would have to start putting work into finding out the cause of Cholera. And if it wasn’t for the cholera epidemics then the middle class would not be care about public health and sanitation. Source 15 is a “report to the members of the Leeds board of health.” The Leeds board of heath will have been funded by the government. This shows me that the government was trying to work on public health. And the government would only spend the money and time on public health if people were questioning the public heath available to them. This makes source 13 useful in answering the question. Source 13 was written by “R .J. Morris.” It is a book called “Cholera 1832: the Social Response

More about How Far Do the Sources Agree That Cholera Epidemics Caused People to Question Public Health Provision in the 19th Century? (20)

Open Document