English Comparitive Essay

2007 Words9 Pages
Evaluate literary texts in different genres: Comparative essay How effectively do Norman MacCaig’s ‘Brooklyn Cop’ and Iain Crichton Smith’s ‘Telegram’ convey the omnipresence and danger of violence and war? Brooklyn Cop and The Telegram This essay will attempt to explain how effectively Norman MacCaig’s ‘Brooklyn Cop’ and Iain Crichton Smith’s ‘Telegram’ convey the omnipresence and danger of violence and war. Both texts deal with the reality of ever present danger and the effects this has on the characters. One difference between the texts is the fact that the violence of war in ‘The Telegram’ is distant, whereas the danger in ‘Brooklyn Cop’ is present in the cop’s day to day life. These differences will be discussed in greater detail and the ideas of both writers will be compared and evaluated. Both literary texts are similar in that they both deal with the fear and effects of violence. Both texts implore the reader to consider the various victims of war and violence. In Norman MacCaigs ‘Brooklyn Cop’ we are given the image of the battle weary cop who lives with the fact that his next day on the beat could be his last. We get a glimpse of the cops fear and anxiety when he says goodbye to his wife. Norman MacCaig articulates this in the line ‘this morning, when he said, “see you, babe” to his wife, he hoped it, he truly hoped it’. This is a powerful moment in the poem as it begs the reader to think about the effect the omnipresence of violence has on both the cop and his wife. As the poem progresses and comes to its conclusion we are then asked to consider who might have to be the cop’s victims. We can see this in the last stanza where it reads ‘and who would be have to be his victims?’ Ultimately the victims are all around us in the form of the cop, his wife and the people he encounters on the beat. This is interesting as the reader is forced to

More about English Comparitive Essay

Open Document