Domestic Policy Dbq

1246 Words5 Pages
“Shifts in party control of the presidency during the twentieth century have typically not brought major shifts in domestic policy.” Assess the validity of this statement. Illustrate your argument by discussing the extent to which two of the following presidents adopted the domestic programs of the previous presidential administrations given in parentheses beneath their names. Franklin D. Roosevelt (Administration of Herbert C. Hoover) Dwight D. Eisenhower (Administrations of Harry S. Truman and Franklin D. Roosevelt) A sizable quantity of United States president frequently adopted and continued the various policies and actions of the preceding executive administration. However, during the twentieth century, two distinct pairs of…show more content…
Roosevelt and Harry S. Truman can be viewed as single Democratic entity that can be contrasted with the decidedly Republican departure that was Eisenhower’s administration. While campaigning in 1952, Eisenhower denounced the ‘statist’ or ‘big government’ programs that comprised Truman's Fair Deal. He did not, however, partake in the extremist perceptions held by some conservative Republicans. Said "Old Guard" Republicans debated cancelling Fair and New Deal programs and lowering the once ever-important government regulation of the economy. Eisenhower held a more moderate political perception that he ultimately dubbed Modern Republicanism. This governmental outlook maintained individual freedom and a decidedly market economy whilst simultaneously ensuring assistance to the unemployed and elderly. Eisenhower’s personal mission was to lead the U.S. down a sort of “middle of the road” path on the razor’s edge separating the unbridled authority of centralized capital and the unrestricted authority of biased statism. Acting as the executive chief, Eisenhower believed that it was the government’s responsibility to allocate specifically distinct benefits to the public. Hence, passed bills increasing minimum wage, expanding Social Security, and establishing the Department of Health, Education and Welfare. As another example of Eisenhower’s modern [and different] outlook on domestic policy, he ambitiously took on the project of…show more content…
Hence, there existed a pronounced disparity betwixt both the policies of Hoover and FDR, and the policies of FDR, Truman, and Eisenhower; the shift from the former to the latter in both instances was irrevocably marked by a dramatic metamorphosis in domestic policy. Whereas Hoover neglected to actively utilize any significant government legislation to directly aid the public, FDR decisive action to aid the country with his New Deal policies. Similarly, whereas FDR’s domestic policies bordered on statism and almost (but not quite) socialist control of the country, Eisenhower took a more moderate approach with his policy of Modern Republicanism whereby the government would simultaneously preserve the individual freedom of U.S. citizens and also guarantee benefits to the unemployed and elderly. Essentially, FDR and Eisenhower did not continue the policies of their predecessors, and did bring about major changes to domestic policy. Thus, the statement, “Shifts in party control of the presidency during the twentieth century have typically not brought major shifts in domestic policy,” can be proven and rendered axiomatically
Open Document