In Fyodor Dostoevsky's 'Deer At Providencia'

915 Words4 Pages
Luanna Perdiz Ms. Palmer IB HL English Oct 28, 2013 Essay Deer at Providencia Suffering Fyodor Dostoevsky, in his book “Suffering is the Sole Origin of Consciousness”, affirms that no one gets through life without experiencing pain. In addition, he mentions, “with maturity and wisdom, you will realize that pain is inevitable”. Likewise, on Dillard’s essay “Deer at Providencia”, she notes the existence of suffering in the world. Hence, through comparisons of different sorts of pains, alliteration and rhetorical questions, she conveys the idea that one and all, whether a human or an animal, must undergo pain and suffering at some point in their lives to achieve preeminent life understanding. On the “Deer at Providencia”, Dillard portrays two cases of mortals experiencing pain. However, the human and the animal perceive their pain in different ways, nevertheless, with the same reaction. At first, Dillard compares both the human and the deer’s…show more content…
However, she does not know why is it imminent. Hence, she constantly asks rhetorical questions, so do McDonald and his wife, to God, who is an abstract figure and will not answer them the way they expect him to do, to try to find an explanation of why they cannot avoid such pain and suffer. They want to know if there is another way to achieve success, or if the achievement of such is only through pain. McDonald asks, “Why does God hate me?”(64), and Dillard knows that no answer will be given to him, so she begs to God to “please explain to Alan in his dignity, to the deer in his dignity, what is going on?”(66). Plus, the author writes McDonald a “letter, cringing”(65) as she strives to comfort him. However, she makes it clear that enduring the pain and understanding the reason for it are very distinct things. Moreover, not only does she question herself about the reason for the pain, but she makes the reader reflect as

More about In Fyodor Dostoevsky's 'Deer At Providencia'

Open Document