To Helen Essay

466 Words2 Pages
Sight Poem Essay Edgar Allen Poe and Hilda Doolittle present contrasting views on Helen of Troy, whose abduction was the cause of the Trojan War. Each poem speaks of Helen in very opposing ways. Edgar Allen Poe presents Helen nearly as a goddess in his poem “To Helen”. Poe uses a gentle, tranquil tone in his poem. He expresses admiration for Helens beauty, comparing her beauty to “Nicean barks of yore.” (line 2) He continues comparing her hair to beautiful flowers, which apparently held a wondrous smell according to Greek mythology. On the contrary, Hilda Doolittle portrays Helen as the cause for a terrible event, where many lives were lost. Doolittle sets the stage for the tone in the first line, “All Greece hates.” (line 1) This tone does not change, while Doolittle does acknowledge Helen’s beauty, the poem ends stating that the world could be a better if she was dead. She also writes, “All Greeece reviles the wan face when she smiles,” (lines 6-7) meaning that all of Greece scorns at the sight of her smile, “hating it deeper still when it grows,” (lines 8-9) The tone used in this poem is obviously a dark, bitter (for the war) and indignant. The title of each of these parts plays a part in the tone of the play, “To Helen” is a title written to make the poem more of a personal note, speaking directly to Helen. Whereas the title “Helen” is a very brief title, alluding to tone, because this brief title reflects anger, skipping the traditions of addressing people. This poem is more talking about Helen, making the poem much less personal, and this is true, because the speaker never addresses Helen personally, when “To Helen” addresses Helen regularly. The writers view on Helen is not the only main element, which differs between their poems; the structure of each poem is drastically different. Although both poems consist of 3 stanzas, Hilda Doolittle’s

More about To Helen Essay

Open Document