Thomas Paine's Analysis Of America

432 Words2 Pages
Paine’s characterization of America seems utopian at the most and unrealistic at the least, especially by modern standards. Perhaps Paine’s opinion held a bit more truth at the time it was written, however its fancifulness has been exaggerated by the passing of time. Paine seems to be in some sort of illusion, describing an America free of conflict or inequality. This America did not exist in 1791, nor does it exist today. The claim that Paine makes that would be most feeble today is that America is a place where the poor are privileged and the rich are not. The United States is increasingly becoming a place where to be poor is to be underprivileged. Though it only sounds logical that a poor person should be underprivileged, it is also true that a country should be judged by the way it treats its worst off citizens. In America today, we have Government officials, many of them Republican, who are vehemently opposed to public programs that benefit the poor. Meanwhile, the richest Americans continue to expand their wealth. The middle class in this country is dying, while the millionaires and billionaires prosper. More and more people are slipping into poverty, while many Republicans oppose tax hikes for the “job creators”. Paine also describes America as a place free of conflict, and as place where “every difficulty retires and all the parts are brought into cordial unison.” This not only does not hold true today, but it contradicts one of the fundamental characteristics of America: the fact that as Americans we are entitled to disagree with each other and argue endlessly about any given subject. Argument and disagreement are huge part of what makes his country great. Despite America’s flaws, the simple fact that every citizen is entitled to voice his or her opinion speaks to our greatness. Paine’s claim is especially untrue today, at a time when political conflict

More about Thomas Paine's Analysis Of America

Open Document