Supreme Court Case Assignment

879 Words4 Pages
Supreme Court Case Assignment CJA/354 Criminal Law Kelleana Strub July 2, 2012 Roy Quisenberry Concerning the U.S. Supreme Court cases the case of Miller v. Alabama has stuck out and peaked interested. This is the case of 14-year-old Evan Miller. On March 20, 2012 the State of Alabama convicted Miller on one count of aggravated murder. He was sentenced to life in prison with parole. Miller’s attorneys appealed with the argument that his conviction violated Evan’s fourteenth and eighth amendment rights. As per (Carrizales, Schultz, & Schulman, 2012) Miller’s attorneys points to the U.S. Supreme Court case Roper v. Simmons and Graham v. Florida, which held that a minor cannot be sentenced to death and that a minor cannot be imprisoned for life for a non-homicidal crime, respectively, as evidence that his conviction contravenes nationally held standards of decency (Carrizales, Schultz, & Schulman, 2012). However, the state responded back that the reference to Roper and Graham cases had no bearing on the particular case. As per (Carrizales, Schultz, & Schulman, 2012) State of Alabama argues that Roper and Graham are factually distinct from this case and that national standards of decency support sentencing a minor to life imprisonment without parole for certain extreme crimes (Carrizales, Schultz, & Schulman, 2012). To get to this portion of the case we must go back to the beginning of the story. On July 15, 2003 Evan Miller just 14 at the time decided to rob and beat his neighbor Cole Cannon. On the day in question Cannon had come over to Evan’s trailer in the trailer park they lived in asking for food. Evan and his friend/codefendant Colby Smith went over to Cannon’s trailer looking for drugs. After an unsuccessful search the boys decided to rob Cannon of his baseball card collection. After they returned to Evan’s Cannon had decided to go

More about Supreme Court Case Assignment

Open Document