Scarlet Letter ': Arthur's Unbearable Guilt'

1126 Words5 Pages
Emma Patrick Mrs. Reitz Honors English II 22 November 2010 (Critical Analysis Final Draft) The Unbearable Guilt Guilt is a mental obsession with the idea of having done wrong. Guilt has more control over some people, than it does to others. In the novel, The Scarlet Letter written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, an infinite amount of guilt is expressed. Both Arthur and Hester are forced to cope with their living guilt in different, yet interesting ways. Within Arthur’s coward self lies his guilt, and openly, lies Hester’s guilt. Arthur Dimmesdale and Hester Prynne commit an immense sin that causes different feelings to erupt throughout the novel, with guilt being the most rising. When it comes to secrecy and guilt, for Hester, it is undeniable.…show more content…
Seven years pass by and Hester and Arthur meet unexpectedly in the forest, both shocked to be in each other’s presence. As the lovers get to talking, Hester questions Arthur asking if he has found peace and in reply Arthur says “None, nothing but despair! What else could I look for, being what I am, and leading such a life as mine? Were I an atheist, a man devoid of conscience, a wretch with coarse and brutal instincts, I might have found peace, long ere now. Nay, I never should have lost it…” (Hawthorne 172). Hester lives with the guilt of having told Arthur that she is married. She is married to the demon that is slowly ruining her lover’s life. When the two meet in the forest after the seven years past, Hester has the opportunity to release the guilt she has buried inside of her for so many years. Arthur admits, “Happy are you, Hester, that wear the scarlet letter openly upon your bosom! Mine burns in secret” (Hawthorne 173). Finally, Hester puts an end to what is her misery, or biggest sin hoping to end Arthur’s as well. She tells Arthur about her husband. He is angry, in shock, and frustrated yet he finds the heart to forgive her. For a split moment, Hester’s guilt ends and she finds peace within…show more content…
The lasting effect of sin for Arthur and Hester is the guilt that they are left with. They force themselves to say goodbye to their peaceful lives and say hello to the guilt that changes them forever. For Arthur and Hester one decision changes the way their lives play out. At times, yes, they are at peace. Overall they suffer with their guilty consciences. Sacrifices are made, and sin and guilt grab hold of Arthur and Hester’s souls, leaving them with the only choice they have, to confess, so that their lives do not
Open Document