Montana 1948: Loyalty To Family: More Important Than Justice?

1034 Words5 Pages
In Montana 1948, loyalty to family is shown to be more important than justice. Do you agree? The novel ‘ Montana 1948’ by Larry Watson, a story about a family that is faced with the most difficult situation that they will ever have to face. In ‘Montana 1948’ loyalty to family is more important than justice in the eyes of some, however in the eyes of others, justice is clearly more important. Family loyalty was a big part of the novel and was shown all throughout the story within the characters of Julian and Wes and how they refused to believe the truth of Frank’s crimes. However, by the end of the novel readers are left with some glimmer of hope as ‘Montana 1948’ is also about Justice overcoming family loyalty. In the end family loyalty…show more content…
In the beginning Wes was seen as a weak man that was nothing but loyal to his family. Wes took over the role of Sheriff after his old man out of loyalty to his father; Wes gave up his dream of becoming a lawyer just so that he could make his father happy and live up to his father’s expectations. “My father set aside his fledgling law practice and took the badge my grandfather offered. It would never occur to my father to refuse.” – David. Deep down Wes always knew the truth about Frank’s crimes, “And my father knew he was guilty”. Regardless of his knowledge of the situation Wes was still prepared to turn a blind eye to it and not investigate to keep loyalty towards his brother. “He’ll have to meet his punishment in the hereafter. “I won’t do anything to arrange it in this life.” When Wes does decide to lock up Frank for his crimes, he still kept his loyalty towards his brother and did not send him to jail; instead he locked Frank up in the basement of the Wes’ family home. Throughout the novel Julian is seen as loyal to Frank the whole time and doesn’t care about Frank’s actions. Julian chooses Frank over justice, and at one point tries to take the law into his own hands to break Frank out of Wes’ basement. Wes and Julian’s loyalty to their family was clearly…show more content…
At the end of the novel Frank goes and commits suicide while being held in the basement of Wes’ house out of family loyalty, so that he doesn’t give a bad name to the rest of the Hayden family because of what he has done. The Hayden family did not tell others that it was a suicide, “It was decided to explain Uncle Frank’s death as an accident”. Out of respect, the Hayden family also never revealed Frank’s crimes, “It was decided to not reveal any of Uncle Frank’s crimes, what purpose would it serve? Besides, as my letter-of-the-law father said, Uncle Frank was never convicted of anything”. However, after Frank’s death, the damage that occurred was just irreparable. “None of these precautions on behalf of Frank’s reputation was enough however to restore harmony in the Hayden family”. The damage was so bad, the Hayden family wouldn’t even talk to each other, “but neither my aunt nor my grandparents would speak to us. Even I understood the symbolism: Frank’s death was an unbridgeable gulf between us.” By the end of the Novel, even after the loyalty shown to Frank as a family member, Julian never forgave Wes, causing Wes and his family to eventually leave Montana and never speak of the incident that happened in ‘Montana’ in that horrible summer of ‘1948’ ‘Montana 1948’ shows in many ways just how important both family loyalty and Justice are to the characters in the book. Wes began off as
Open Document