Insanity: A Case Study

839 Words4 Pages
1. Define, compare, and contrast the concepts of not guilty by reason of insanity and guilty but mentally ill. What are the legal and practical consequences of each of these verdicts. 2. Discuss the evolution of the standards of insanity. Include the following: a. The M’Naghten rule b. The irresistible impulse exemption c. The Durham test d. The ALI (American Law Institute) standard or Brawner rule 3. Discuss the similarities and differences between the psychological conception of mental illness and the legal concept of insanity. 4. Discuss the similarities and differences between evaluating for criminal intent (insanity defense) and evaluating for competence to stand trial. a. What are the elements that must be established in considering competence? b. What are the…show more content…
Discuss the controversies over syndromes such as PAS (Parental Alienation Syndrome), CSAAS (Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome) and FMS (False Memory Syndrome). 18. What is PTSD? How are rape trauma syndrome and battered woman syndrome similar to and different from PTSD? 19. Discuss the relationship between victim blame and psychological recovery for the victim. Distinguish between victim blame by others and self blame, and between behavioral blame and characterological blame. 20. What are the advantages of using PTSD instead of RTS in accounting for the reactions of rape victims? What are the disadvantages? 21. What are the arguments for and against using anatomically detailed dolls when interviewing children who may have been sexually abused? 22. Defense attorneys now routinely attack child testimony as being coached or planted. What is the basis of such charges? What does the research show about children’s suggestibility? 23. What are the elements used to determine if a young child is competent to testify? 24. What are the arguments for and against shielding a child witness from visual contact with a defendant? What has the USSC said about such
Open Document