The Tsar himself was responsible for the fall of the Romanovs in 1917, mostly due to how he was not suited to the role as the Tsar. This was due toAYASHA IMRAN and start a revolution. Nicholas II dissolved the Duma and introduced bread rationing which caused families at home to suffer and strikes and demonstration increased due to tsars rationing threats, working conditions and inflation. The Tsar did not do anything successful to stop these strikes or to stop the inflation. His tactics were wrong which caused himself the responsible for the fall of the Romanovs in 1917.
All these led to the increase in demand for more democracy and affect the wellbeing of the Romanov dynasty. Secondly, I would discuss about the medium-term causes. They include the defeat in the Russo-Japanese war, the creation of duma, and the failure of political reforms because of Tsar Nicholas II’s firm decision of never giving up autocratic power. In 1905, the defeat in the Russo-Japanese war led to a series of social unrest, such as formation of soviets, general strikes and political killings. These photos are evidence of what some people did to express their dissatisfactory in1905, one about a demonstration and one about a train turned over by some striking workers.
The increasing pressures of World War 1 combined with years of injustice, lead to the fall of Russian Romanov Tsar Nicholas 2 in March 1917. Forced to step down from power, Nicholas was replaced by a Provisional government committed to continuing the war. However there was increasing losses and fear of German advance on Moscow showed what little support remained for the war and, undermined the provisional government’s authority. Hoping to aggravate the uproar, the Germans were said to have secretly transported, an exile Vladimir Lenin from Switzerland to Russia. In November Lenin led a group of Bolsheviks from the Russia's Social Democrat Party, in a successful attempt to gain power in St. Petersburg.
How far was the First World War the main cause of the fall of the Romanovs in 1917? In March 1917, the Tsar Nicholas II made his decision to abdicate the throne thus, causing the fall of the monarchy in Russia. The First World War was most certainly a factor that caused the fall of the Romanovs however; there are many other factors that must be considered. At the beginning of the war, there was a strong sense of patriotisms in Russia due to excellent war performance. The decline in Russia’s war performance caused morale in the army as well as in the country to also decrease.
Part of Alexander III’s problem was the legacy left by his father who had begun reforms which raised expectations of major change within Russia. Other problems he faced were that Russia was economically underdeveloped, he had to keep the large multi-ethnic empire together and also the country was still recovering from the death of Alexander II. As a result Alexander III pursued a policy of counter-reform. Counter-reform was partly a reaction to the murder of Alexander II, but Alexander III also believed that his father’s ‘Great Reforms’ had been a mistake, weakening Tsarism and leaving it insecure. His policy was to undo the reforms as far as possible and he did this through a number of social and political changes.
Another contributory factor to the February Revolution could have been the Russo Japanese War, this important event undermined the Tsar’s power; Firstly, Russia suffered a great of humiliation when the Japanese forces defeated the Russian army is Manchuria, followed by Russia being defeated at the Battle of Tsushima; these were two big humiliating wars that Russia lost. The war had an enormous effect impact on Russia. There were many failures, however, there weren’t many successes, except, in 1914, Russia beat
Assess the proposition that WW1 was primarily responsible for the downfall of the Tsarist regime in Russia in 1917. The arrival of WW1 had a significant influence and was the catalyst to the demise of the Romanov dynasty in 1917, however the attitude of the Russian people lead on by centuries of heinous conditions and unfair ruling by the Autocracy of the Romanovs had ultimately shaped the downfall of the Tsarist Regime. Events such as Bloody Sunday, introduction of Grigori Rasputin and the Bread riots (the events of early 1917) were primary causes to the collapse of Tsarist power in Russia. One of most imperative and essential events contributing to the collapse of Tsarist autocracy in Russia was on the January 9th 1905, the Bloody Sunday protest, the result of the events on January 9th 1905 played an essential role in the revolution of 1917. This protest took place in St Petersburg and was peaceful and contained, however due to Tsar Nicholas II’s drastic predetermined demands the order to kill caused the death of up to 1000 people including women and children.
This continued cycle of unjust behaviour towards the serfs led to the beginning of distrust and a lack of faith in the monarchy from the public. The people of Russia continued to lose their faith in the monarchy when Tsar Nicholas came to the throne – one of the turning points for the reputation of the Tsar was the Russo-Japanese war in 1904/1905. This war was particularly significant because of the humiliation Russia suffered in this time: They had expected to win the war easily, as Russia was considered a huge and powerful country compared to Japan. However, when they were defeated easily by the Japanese, it was seen as an embarrassment, as well as an example of how the Russian army was not as powerful as it seemed. This, although not
How far was the First World War the main cause of the fall of the Romanov’s in February 1917?’ (30 marks) The Romanov’s were the ruling family of Russia from 1613 to 1917. This, however, all ended when Tsar Nicholas II abdicated the throne as the result of what would become known as the February Revolution, although there were many factors that affected Nicholas’ decision. To a certain extent, you could blame the First World War for the downfall of the Romanov’s. However, it could also be argued that it was existing problems and the Tsar’s unwillingness to change that ultimately resulted with the Romanov’s downfall. World War One was the spark that ignited revolution.
World War 1 was the major factor which led to the collapse of the Romanov Dynasty and put an end to Tsardom in February, 1917. Without the war and the hardship and strain on the Russian economy and moral a revolution would not have happened at this point in time. This is not to say a revolution would not have eventually happened, as many of the ingredients needed were already present. However, what World War 1 did was to heighten the discontent throughout society enough for it to revolt the upper classes in society where annoyed because Nicholas II had left Russia to be ran effectively by Rasputin whilst he was away at the front line leading to bribery and corruption plaguing the Russian political system; the lower class in Russia where angered by the total war attitude of the