Cultural Context in Sive, I'M Not Scared & Brooklyn

1634 Words7 Pages
6th Year English Comparative Studies (Paper 2) Mr Traynor 2013 A reader can feel uncomfortable with the values and attitudes presented in texts (2011 HL) I have studied the novel ‘Brooklyn’ (BN) by Colm Tóibín. Tóibín’s novel offered me a fascinating glance back into 1950s Ireland, a time when attitudes and value systems are very different from the ones I know today. While 2012 society is not perfect, I however, did feel uncomfortable with attitudes towards social class and marriage, as well as how the Catholic Church was valued in society. I was shocked at how entrenched social class divides were in 1950s Enniscorthy. Enniscorthy was a town were men and women were almost ranked on their social position in the community and everybody knew everybody. It was amusing to read Eilis’ mother ruminating over the many members of extended families in the town. Eilis’ mother appeared to have an almost encyclopaedic mind when it came to other people’s families. However I found it slightly uncomfortable that Mrs Kelly could find out all she needed to know about Eilis from gossiping to other people. Indeed Mrs Kelly’s shop provided the focal point for gossip and rumours in the town. While I did find Mrs Kelly’s shop a quaint old style grocery store where locals could meet up and exchange stories, I like Eilis, was unsettled by the manner in which Mrs Kelly treated her customers. Mrs Kelly only sold tomatoes and the freshest bread for her favoured customers. For others she treated with disdain, as if they were not worthy to be in her shop. I am extremely glad that I am not judged according to my social class when I go into a shop. Tóibín offers the reader a unique view of attitudes towards marriage in 1950s Ireland. Eilis’s marriage to Tony was founded on love, however the thought of marriage seemed to suffocate Eilis. I admired Eilis’s determination to
Open Document