Critique Of A Jail: Article Analysis

1153 Words5 Pages
Sean Kohler JLA 150 Professor Sharpe Journal Critique Article: The article being critiqued is “Jails and Public Health Service Delivery and Empirical Knowledge: the Impact of Jail Population “Flow””. It was published in the American Journal of Criminal Justice 37 in 2012 and is on pages 200-208. Synopsis: First the author states that jails are the perfect place to reach a population of people who are at high risk for disease, disorders, and injuries. There is a huge number of people going through the jail system (about 8.5 million annually) and as a result it makes jails an easy place to perform health interventions. Some important terms are then defined for future use throughout the article. Flow is the general movement of the…show more content…
The individual was then booked and processed. After completing the intake process a more thorough medical screening takes place before appearing in the courtroom. By Florida law it is required to do this immediately or at booking. After about 48 hours about 60% of the detainees were released from jail. Other than the brief medical screenings there is little hope that detainees will be interviewed about other medical issues. After about 10 days in the OCCD jail it is required that detainees undergo more rigorous health examinations, but by that time 74% of those detained had been released. Only about one quarter of the jail population is there long enough for diagnosis or initiation of a treatment process. . They concluded that disease screening, immunization, and prevention education is only really feasible for a small portion of those going in and out of jail. Only about one quarter which were mostly felony offenders. They decided that it was unreasonable to think that delivery of health services beyond brief health promotion and treatment of minor conditions were…show more content…
In that case I think that it is important to have them undergo medical screening. They are going to be detained around other people with the possibility of getting them sick as well. It was a bit of a surprise to me that they waited ten days to examine these individuals. They knew before those ten days that these people were going to be there for a while, and that seems like too much time to let go by without having these people checked out. To go to a public school it’s required to have a physical every couple of years, and I wonder how many of the people detained in jail have not been to a doctor in years, and may be getting sicker and possibly spreading it to others. In another article I read called “Chronic Medical Conditions among Jail Detainees in Residential Psychiatric Treatment: A Latent Analysis” published in the Journal of Urban Health August, 2011 there are studies that show that detainees with mental illnesses have significantly higher rates of chronic medical conditions such as asthma, diabetes, and infectious diseases. There is also evidence to suggest that long-term detainees are at higher risk of having mental illness, and therefore, according to this study, are at higher risk of having infectious diseases. If this is certainly the case than the importance of screening long-term detainees is crucial. (Swartz,

More about Critique Of A Jail: Article Analysis

Open Document