“Book 9 Shows Odysseus at His Most Successful and Most Foolish” to What Extent Do You Agree with This Assessment of His Behavior?

1038 Words5 Pages
“Book 9 shows Odysseus at his most successful and most foolish” To what extent do you agree with this assessment of his behavior? Throughout book nine Odysseus shows us a varied coalesce of successful and foolish acts. These acts are structured so that initially Odysseus makes a dire mistake in a troublesome situation, then learns from it with a second acts of bravery in another but which ultimately backfires and so in his third encounter with danger he successes proving his leadership and emphasising traits which make him seem more heroic: this is prevalent throughout books nine, ten and eleven as a generic Homeric structure of Odysseus’s story telling to Alcinous. This to us makes Odysseus seem more realistic and human while he maintains his Homeric hero qualities; intern extending on his success and emphasising it through his foolish failures. In book nine we see initial success when Odyssues reaches the island of Ismarus , home of the Cicones, where they attack and gain a “vast plunder” , this initial success reiterates Odysseus’s success at Troy and his , as well as his men’s, fighting capabilities and power. Unfortunately this success is hugely overshadowed when Odysseus told his men they have to “escape with all possible speed” as to uphold their victory and not to be met with opposition in its presence, but his “fools of men refused”: this initially place the blame on the men but this in itself, as Odysseus is saying it, shows a lack of good leadership on his part, as he himself is unable to make the men follow his orders, and so the blame for his own downfall is shifted onto others, leading to the Cicones gaining re-enforcements and so six of his “ strong greaved comrades from each ship were killed” due to this lack of leadership . This in itself does not show Odysseus’s foolishness directly but it reveals a more vulnerable corrupt side to him,

More about “Book 9 Shows Odysseus at His Most Successful and Most Foolish” to What Extent Do You Agree with This Assessment of His Behavior?

Open Document