Benefits Of Nationalizing Health Care

1711 Words7 Pages
Nationalized Health Care Kenny Robbins Robert Morris University Professor Sneberger COSK1221 December 6, 2012 Nationalizing health care is a very big and controversial topic in today’s society. There are many costs and benefits to each side of nationalizing health care. Nationalizing health care would be a great asset to many Americans that are currently uninsured, it would however be very costly, and it would come with a high risk of corruption. Nationalizing health care is a popular topic that is pushed for by many politicians. The current health care system that is in use in the United States is the best form of healthcare established. Nationalizing healthcare would be a great asset to many U.S. citizens that currently uninsured.…show more content…
The quality of health care that patients receive would be greatly reduced. Nationalizing health care reduces patient and doctor flexibility leading to poorer treatment of patients. Patients are not likely to curb their doctor visits and drug costs if it is free, so total costs of health care will be several times what they are now. In order to cut costs of health insurance price and salary controls on drugs, medical equipment, and medical services will probably be put into effect. People who live in countries that have nationalized health care have to wait on very long waiting lists before they are treated sometimes. For example there was a woman in Canada that needed a brain C-T scan but the waiting list in Canada was six months long. So her sister brought to the United States to have the test done and they found that she had a brain tumor and needed surgery immediately. Had she waited in Canada she would have died waiting for treatment (Erbe, 2009). The U.S. has a higher quality of health care than most other nations around the world. Nationalizing health care does not insure that everyone will have equal access to the health care system. For example seniors in Canada and the United Kingdom report having much more difficulty the U.S. seniors in obtaining health care benefits (Longley, 2006). Nationalizing health care gives health care to the deeply impoverished but at the expense of the…show more content…
(2010, March 21). Health care reform bill summary: A look at what's in the bill. Retrieved from http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20000846-503544/health-care-reform-bill-summary-a-look-at-whats-in-the-bill/ Longley, R. (2006, February 16). Should the u.s. adopt a nationalized health care system. Retrieved from http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/medicarehealthinsurance/i/nathealthins_2.htm Messerli, J. (n.d.). Should the government provide free universal health care for all. Retrieved from http://www.balancedpolitics.org/universal_health_care.htm Toulmin Claim- That nationalized health care would greatly help the United States. Stated Reasons- It would help reduce the economic deficit. It would insure many Americans that are currently not insured. It would provide free health care to all American citizens. Grounds- It is estimated to reduce the deficit by nearly $1.4 trillion over 20 years. Warrant- That there are no major problems or downfalls to nationalized health care. Backing- The quality of medical help would decrease. It would be paid for through taxes and would create many
Open Document