'What Does He Mean When He Says That Swans Are Brilliant Creatures'?

371 Words2 Pages
WEEK #2 JOURNAL Directions: To complete this week's journal assignment, you need to answer all of the following questions, but you do not have to write extensively on each one. Type your answers this template, save the document doc or rtf, and then drop it in the Digital Dropbox. These exercises are due by January 17th. I. "Join the conversation," page 294. Question #1 Do you find this poem beautiful? Would you be inclined to use a different term to characterize it? Is there a special element in this poem that leads you to believe that this is a beautiful poem? Can one argue about beauty? Question #2 What is the scene that the speaker describes in lines 1-14? What is the nature of the change that he describes in lines 15-30? Question #3 What does he mean when he says that swans are "brilliant creatures"? Question #4 Can you explain…show more content…
What would be your argument against it? Question #5 Have you ever had an experience similar to Yeats? What was the experience? What was the response you had when it happened? Do you think about the experience differently now? II. "Join the Conversation," page 295. Question #1 What does it mean for the pool players to say that they are "cool," and not just "cool," but "real cool"? Question #2 Why does Brooks give seven speakers? Why not one? Would that have been more focused and thus more effective? Question #3 What does Brooks gain by organizing the lines as she does? Question #4 What is your argument to the claim that the poem would be better in third-person plural? Question #5 Does the information provided add or detract from you experience of the poem? Question #6 Is it accurate--or misleading--to say that this poem presents an argument? III. In Chapter 11, refer to the five questions on page 308 under "Join the conversation." Choose one question to answer. Question #____ Type your response

More about 'What Does He Mean When He Says That Swans Are Brilliant Creatures'?

Open Document