How Far Do You Agree That the Changing Priorities of the Five-Year-Plans Suggest That Stalin Had No Overall Scheme for Soviet Economic Policy, but Was Merely Responding to Events?

735 Words3 Pages
Question: How far do you agree that the changing priorities of the Five-Year-Plans suggest that Stalin had no overall scheme for Soviet economic policy, but was merely responding to events? Answer: The period from 1928 to 1941 witnessed the implementation of three Five-Year-Plans under Stalin’s government. As each plan progressed to the next phase, there were various accompanying alternations in their priorities. There is evidence to suggest that Stalin had no thorough economic plan but was merely making adjustments in the event of the unexpected. However, throughout three sessions, Stalin also well adhered to some complete policies related to heavy industry and this had become the key principle in Soviet economic policy. The First Five Year Plan revealed so many drawbacks that many senior figures in Soviet government got to consider varioud modifications in its priorities. The transition from First to Second Five Plan was marked by a shift in communications sector. As a shortcoming of First Five Year Plan, the economy was unable to transport the vast quantities of raw materials produced and in response to this unexpected problem, improving infrastructure was a new priority for Soviet economics planners. Also during this period, there was an important historical event, Hitler was elected as German Chancellor and the moderates claimed this would pose a threat of war to Russia, suggesting priorities to be diverted to peasants. Accordingly, government carried out reforms on collective farms and moderating the anti-kulak policy to win over peasant’s support.Following Kirov’s murder at the end of 1934, the moderates lost its influence. In place of it, Stalin revised the Plan again, diverting funds from the production of consumer goods to investment in Russia’s military resources. Again, the priority was modified in due course
Open Document