Comparing Hills Like White Elephants and June Birthing

623 Words3 Pages
Many stories share similar devices and distinctive merits to convey the story’s message and allow readers to have their own interpretation of the story. An important component of literature is the ability to comparatively evaluate two elements or products of work. Short stories are excellent for comparing and contrasting because of the details and themes conveyed in a length shorter than a novel that readers can understand the same way. In “Hills like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway and “June Birthing”by Joyce Carol Oates, certain aspects makes them similar, different, and even one more interesting than the other. Both stories can be viewed similarly in several ways. The setting in both stories takes place during travels. In “ Hills Like White Elephants,” the man and the woman are at a train station, whereas in " June Birthing " the man and woman meet on a country road. The different paths both represent the couples and the path of their relationship. The female characters are also similar in the sense of their helplessness and vulnerability. The unnamed female in “ Hills Like White Elephants” is very dependent on the male character. She needs him to communicate to order her drinks because they’re in Spain and she’s unable to speak Spanish. In “\June Birthing,” Kathe faces a problem when she encounters a newborn fawn. She becomes almost paralyzed while trembling because of her incapability to do anything and knowing nothing about how to help the fawn. “She was thinking , I must do something, I must do something, but the immediacy of the tiny creature, its extraordinary physical beauty and terrible frailty distracted her, scattered her thoughts like a flock of birds frightened by a gunshot,” ( Oates 499) up until Lyle Carter arrives. Both female also tries to stop each conflict by asking to end the conversation. Along with similarities, both

More about Comparing Hills Like White Elephants and June Birthing

Open Document