What Are Some Key Differences Between How the Mencius and the Zhuangzi View Spontaneity?

660 Words3 Pages
Spontaneity, can be the condition of being spontaneous; spontaneous behavior or action. Towards it, both Zhuangzi and Mencius had different interpretations on it. The differences can be divided into three aspects. The first difference is their nature. Mencius’s view is within us. Mencius thought spontaneity is just our spontaneous feelings in a situation. In other words, it is human-centered, seldom related to others or the surrounding environments. Mencius has used a story to explain it: when people see a child nearly fall in a well, they will try to save the child even they do not know the child (2A/6). People’s reactions are automatically and instinctively, without thinking of any rewards or appreciations and this is the spontaneity suggested by Mencius. Thus, it is always unchangeable because spontaneity is from our inborn heart. Zhuangzi’s view is outside us. He thought spontaneity is the dao of the nature and environment-centered which is uncontrollable by us. People’s dao are just parts of a big dao and we need to follow it! Zhuangzi said if we want to swim well, we should follow the dao of water and forget your own dao (p.13). The spontaneity suggested by him is nothing related to us! The second difference is should we follow the spontaneity. Mencius suggested that although our spontaneous reactions can reveal part of our goodness, it is not necessary best for us to follow the spontaneity. Just like the story of King Xuan and the ox (1A/7), King Xuan’s decision was inappropriate so it was better not to replace ox by sheep. Sometimes our spontaneity affects our behaviours, but it may not be appropriate and suitable. So we should not always follow our spontaneity and need to think twice before acting. Zhuangzi has an opposite view with Mencius. He thought that we should follow the spontaneity which is the best way for us to live. In the example

More about What Are Some Key Differences Between How the Mencius and the Zhuangzi View Spontaneity?

Open Document