Urban Indigenous Housing Issues In Redfern Summary

1478 Words6 Pages
REGZ9255 University Orientation & Study Skills 2 Assignment 2: Critical Review Name: Alexis A. Castro Robles Student No.: 5023945 Teacher: Jamie Roberts Class: Tuesday A Critical Review of Four Sources on Housing in Redfern (part of the City of Sydney Local Government Area) by Alexis A. Castro Robles INTRODUCTION This critical review will examine four different sources that address the issue of housing in one particular part of the City of Sydney Local Government Area, the Inner-City suburb of Redfern. The sources are a book chapter, 'Cosmopolitan Metropolitanism (Or The Indifferent City)' from Cities of Whiteness by Wendy S. Shaw; a journal article, 'Urban Indigenous Housing issues in Redfern' by Jacqui Wilkinson;…show more content…
The fourth chapter of the book, 'City of Whiteness' by Wendy Shaw (2007, pp. 136-172) discusses the aspect of urban consolidation in Inner Sydney. It presents how these areas were transformed from working class enclaves and industrial landscapes into an urbanised cosmopolis, with modern apartments that appeal to the affluent. Redfern is mentioned as an example of this transformation and the author points out that Aboriginal residents are neglected and stigmatised in the process. Similarly, the journal article of Jacqui Wilkinson (2005) addresses the urban consolidation of Redfern but focuses in detail on its negative effects on Indigenous Australians. The purpose of the article is to promote the right to adequate housing for Aborigines in Redfern, where strategies such as those from the Redfern-Waterloo Authority barely addressed the issue. The author presents 'The Block' to exemplify this issue, as the Aboriginal residents struggle to live in appropriate conditions (i.e. overcoming the problem of overcrowding) but remain socially disadvantaged, in comparison to the broader Redfern…show more content…
The article is notable for how well invested the arguments of the author towards the Aborigines are. The author presents several examples where the basic rights of the Indigenous population in Redfern are breached, along with some statistics about this group's residency situations with an empathetic approach. On the other hand, a major fault of this source is that, even though it might have raised awareness for the reader about the housing situation for the Indigenous people of Redfern, she fails to provide an appropriate solution. Instead, she finalises her argument by simply relying on what housing authorities had proposed and previously attempted to

More about Urban Indigenous Housing Issues In Redfern Summary

Open Document