Guns, Germs, and Steel

647 Words3 Pages
When comparing two vastly different cultures, the question arises, why do certain cultures progress further and faster than others? Through studying societies around the world and comparing them to an underdeveloped society in Papua New Guinea, Jared Diamond concluded in the film Guns, Germs, and Steel that the development of more efficient farming and food sources are the root of this inequality. Respected anthropologists, Franz Boas, who developed the idea of “cultural relativism” and the importance of environment to anthropological studies, and Carl Marx, who stated that without higher economic and social classes new ideas aren’t transmitted into societies, support Diamond’s original argument that protein is the base of the inequality of societal development. Franz Boas supported Jared Diamond’s theories through his idea of “cultural relativism”, stating that anatomical, physiological, and mental characteristics of human beings serve no purpose in anthropological studies. He believed it was more vital to study the events that led to the establishment of various cultures. He also affirmed that the traits of a society evolve from historical developments that include cultural and environmental forces (Crandall 14). Boas’ theory that environment characteristics can attribute to the development of a culture support Diamond’s studies, stating that environmental deficiencies in Papua New Guinea were the cause for the underdeveloped farming system. Boas also thought that cultural traits of any group of people are the products of historical developments, thus supporting Diamond’s idea that because new farming technology and techniques had never been developed in Papua New Guinea, progress has been greatly hindered (Crandall 15). Boas’ idea of “cultural relativism” supports Diamond’s theory that environmental forces can cause the diversity in societal development.
Open Document