God Bless America? or This Land Is Your Land?

1068 Words5 Pages
If you were to ask a local American what songs are the most devoted to their nation, the most popular answers you received beside the national anthemn would most probably be “God bless America” and “This land is your land”. There is no doubt that these two songs have the same theme of patriotism, however when one take a deeper look into these, they may find that the two possess some distinctions that make them unique from one another. The differences may be in term of the background that the song was composed, the meaning of the lyric and who or what the lyric was addressing at that point of time. Here and now this essay will evaluate the similarities as well as the various differences between these 2 famous songs. In addition my personal experience when liestening to these songs. A brief glance into the history of “God bless America” and “This land is your land” shows that both songs were composed during the darkest periods in American history, and the world’s as a whole. “God bless America” was written around 1918 by Irving Berlin but only became popular after 1938, when the World War II happened. This has later become the signature song of Kate Smith, a vocalist who sang the well-known revised version. However Woody Guthrie was not so moved by the song because according to him, it painted an unrealistic picture of america then. Hence in 1940 he wrote his own version in protest of the unrealistic version “God bless America”. Consequently a song called “This land is your land” was recorded in 1944 and published one year later. The Great Depression was also seen to have ended around this point of time. In comparison of the lyric, Woody’s piece of music painted a clearer social picture of 1930s and 40s in a sense that it addressed real social issues like massive unemployment, starvation and future uncetainty which were threatening the life of millions every
Open Document