Detective Narratives Essay

982 Words4 Pages
Rebecca Marley Response Paper 1 April 9, 2012 "Silver Blaze" and "The Witness for the Prosecution" each contain case-closing evidence that leave both detectives to solve their cases differently, leading to opposite conclusions. Holmes and Mayhearne equally emerge themselves into their investigations, hoping to solve the mystery to the murder. As evidence starts to develop, the differences between Sherlock Holmes and Mr. Hayhearne appear. As we discover that "Silver Blaze" has a successful outcome for the mystery and "The Witness for the Prosecution" does not, we realize that the outcome relies on the decisions made by the detectives. As Sherlock Holmes fights to prove the authorities wrong about the conclusion of the murder and kidnapping of the horse, clues link together and prove his intuition correct. Before he discovers the strong evidence, you really get a strong sense of Sherlock Holmes confidence and professionalism as a detective when him and the police debate about Simpson. Not giving into the obvious solution is a great sign for a smart detective. When Holmes finds the horse foot prints while his other smart ideas start to unwind one by one , I felt great comfort and faith in Holmes his ability to crack this case. The way Holmes uses his instinct and natural intuition leaves the audience and myself anxious and eager because we believe he will piece it together eventually. Even tiny sentences he says like, "Hum!" said Holmes. "Somebody knows something, that is clear!" (97), keeps the readers comfortable that he is on to something. There is a nice progression in this case and the way this detective managed to find the evidence, rather than have them given to him. Holmes used the evidence he found and made smart accusations that the police would not have been able to create. He found the horse and foot

More about Detective Narratives Essay

Open Document