Cpr Cases Essay

972 Words4 Pages
Glenwood Gardens CPR Case: independent living Home Defends Nurse Who Refused To Help Ailing Patient” March 4th, 2010 On March 6th 2013, an 87-year-old woman named Lorraine Bayless died in the dining hall of her elder home. The elder home, called Glenwood Gardens is located in California and is owned by a Tennessee-based company called Brookdale Senior Living. While she Ms. Bayless was on the floor fighting for her life, a nurse called 911. For seven minutes, Tthe dispatcher asked her, for seven minutes, the nurse to perform CPR on the patient. However, the nurse refused to do so, on the woman by claiming that it was against company policy to perform CPR on those living in the home. The EMTs arrived at the scene some 7 minutes and a few seconds later, but by then, Bayless had breathed her last. As I will argue in this paper, Eeven though Bayless had wanted a natural death without any life prolonging intervention, the nurse had a preexisting duty to attempt to save the old woman’s life. (State in one sentence what that duty is based on – her professional obligation, the principle of beneficence/nonmaleficence, or what?) Kant advocatesd duty-based or deontological ethics, which focuses on what people do, not the consequences of their actions. People have the duty to do the right thing, even if it produces less good. In the case of Lorraine Bayless, the nurse’s’ refusal to perform CPR violated her duty to provide basic medical help. While doctors are required to follow the Hippocratic Oath, nurses follow The Nightingale Pledge. In the pledge is a sentence that says, “[I will] devote myself to the welfare of those committed to my care.” Nurses have a duty to help those in need of medical attention. Kant emphasizes the value of every human being and focuses on giving equal respect to all. If would not normally let a person on the street suffering cardiac arrest
Open Document