Comparing Detectives Essay

1664 Words7 Pages
Essay: Comparing Setting, detectives, suspects and stories Intro: The two stories I will be contrasting and comparing in my essay are called ‘The man with the twisted lip ‘by Conan Doyle and ‘The case of the dubious daddy’ by McCall Smith. The Man with the twisted lip fits the detective genres because as this story develops and unfolds the truth, new characters are introduced e.g. Boone which is linked to some way to the mystery. Also because the Author drops clues that might help the reader unravel the truth. In The story of ‘The case of the dubious daddy’ fits the detective genre because the main characters in it have reasons and intensions which are revealed through dialogue. Also the end comes quickly and there is a brief ending. Both stories create suspense by the theme of lying .Slowly discovering the truth by the help of hints mentioned in the story to help the reader unravel the truth. The detective Sherlock Holmes in Doyle’s story is portrayed as a strong minded and a determined personality. He is mentioned to as ‘An unsolved problem upon his mind would go for days and even for a week’. This suggests that He devotes a lot of thought in willing to solve the situation without any relaxation for large periods of time. Doyle’s use of the phrase ‘Unsolved problem upon his mind ‘gives the reader the impression that he is a very hardworking and independent man who is committed to what he does. In addition it makes the reader feel that Sherlock Holmes is a very enthusiastic character, would face any obstacles and challenges to solve particular situations. Similarly the reader also feels sympathy for him in a way for not havening enough relaxation time to himself and busy stressing out for others. However The female detective in McCall smith story, Mma Ramostwe is portrayed as a sympathetic and thoughtful personality. She is referred to as ‘my brothers and sisters,
Open Document