Compare and Contrast ‘in Paris with You’ and ‘She Walks in Beauty’

832 Words4 Pages
Compare and Contrast ‘In Paris with You’ and ‘She Walks in Beauty’ ‘In Paris with you’ is a modern poem about a man rebounding from a failed relationship with a new romantic encounter, “I admit I’m on the rebound” in Paris; a stereotypical ‘city of love’. She walks in Beauty is a traditional courtly love poem, a description of a beautiful woman who “walks in beauty” typical of the romantic period Byron wrote in. The use of Paris as the setting for this poem, known as ‘the city of love’ is very cliché and a contrast with the first line “Don’t talk to me of love” which is unexpected considering the title “In Paris with you” implies a story of a couple in love. Throughout the poem there is a lexical field of war “wounded…hostage…marooned.” This lexical field implies that love is a battle and has the power to bring disaster in its wake. The themes of this poem are set out in a syllogistic manner; in the first two stanzas he talks about his past and what he’s been through “resentful at the mess I’ve been though”. In the third and fourth stanza he narrows down to the present; where he is now, in Paris but then the hotel room “remain here in this sleazy Old hotel room”, creating a sense of intimacy as if they were in their own immediate little world. His description of the famous French sights “sod off to sodding Notre Dame” shows that for him, the two of them being together in their own world is much more important than seeing the famous tourist attractions. Describing the hotel room they are in as “sleazy” and having a “crack across the ceiling” gives the poem a sense of realism and realistic views on what love is like, typical to modern literature, and a twist on traditional courtly love. similar to ‘Come, Live with me and be my Love’ by Cecil Day- Lewis. Who in his parody of Marlowe’s ‘The Passionate Shepherd to his Love’ talks of the realism and honesty of love
Open Document