Unit 4: Implications Essay

802 Words4 Pages
Tiffany Cartmell Unit 4: Implications b) Do you agree with the idea expressed? Justify your point of view and discuss its implications for understanding religion and human experience. ? (20) The idea that personal relationships and morality do not conflict is a strong argument for a number of reason that have been put forward by Lafollette and other philosophers. Firstly the argument in the passage is that personal relationships are necessary to develop impartiality towards acquaintances or strangers. This is said to be because if someone never develops personal ties with their family and friends they will not learn the necessary skills to become a moral person. E.g. if a child is not shown how to have close personal ties with family…show more content…
Therefore this is saying that they in fact conflict in situations and that they should not but that impartiality should come before our personal ties. However it is not saying we cannot have personal relationship but that only up to a certain point can we extend the love for those. Rachel’s view is not completely nonsense. Its significant point is that impartiality is vital to our understanding of morality and something deeply important we should not give up. Impartiality in morality for e.g. explains why we find sexism and racism morally wrong for it is wrong not just because it happens to those we are close to but because it happens to anyone at all. Also although we may like to lavish attention on our nearest and dearest this can be over the top and seen as unfair to the less well off. E.g. a mother spending £1000’s on her child’s second birthday wrong when there are other people’s children starving and dying? This suggests that personal relationships can therefore conflict with personal relationships. Also with this view it would eliminate some of the benefits of having personal relations such wellbeing and self-worth from being loved and loving in return with those of who we are compatible

More about Unit 4: Implications Essay

Open Document