To What Extent Do Sources J and K Agree That the Conservatives Followed a Policy of Consensus with the Labour Government of 1945-1951?

336 Words2 Pages
To what extent do sources J and K agree that the Conservatives followed a policy of consensus with the Labour Government of 1945-1951? Both source J and K talk about Butskellism and the composite of Mr Butskell; one thing that indicates a policy of consensus with the previous Labour Government and the Conservatives. However source J points towards an agreement in ‘moderation from the government side’ and source K points towards an agreement in economics. However source k also points towards a disagreement in how to achieve said economics. In source J Butskellism (or Mr Butskell) is the combination of R.A. Butler, Conservative’s Chancellor of the Exchequer; and Hugh Gaitskell, Labour’s previous Chancellor of the Exchequer. Butskellism shows a consensus between Labour and the Conservatives as it means the combination of a Keynesian economy agreed upon by both Butler and Gaitskell. This is also seen in source K through the reference to Mr Butskell (Also the composite of Butler and Gaitskell). These sources both agree there is the thought of consensus however they don’t fully support the idea that there was any policy consensus between the two. Although there is some agreement seen through Butskellism, in source K when Butler writes ‘Both of us…spoke the language of Keynesianism. But we spoke it with different accents and with a different emphasis.’ This shows how they wanted the same result; however they had differences in getting there. Whereas in source J there isn’t much reason to believe they had their differences. In source J there is no mention of either Butler or Gaitskell, only Mr Butskell, which shows a resounding consensus between the two. Sources J and K agree to a certain extent that the Conservatives followed a policy of consensus with the Labour Government of 1945-1951 as; although Butskellism is the main theme seen throughout both sources,
Open Document