Review Of Jonathan Harr's A Civil Action

1066 Words5 Pages
A Civil Action by Jonathan Harr New York: Vintage Books 1995. 502 pages. reviewed by Elizabeth Jung POLI 214 A Dr. Morgan Scott Roanoke College December 6, 2010 A Civil Action, Jonathan Harr’s book, is a gripping, suspenseful tale following the Woburn case. It is the true story of families from a small industrial town in Massachusetts suing two U.S corporations for leukemia deaths and other health related problems. It is also the true story of a Boston lawyer named Jan Schlichtmann who takes on the case for reasons only divulged at the end of the story. This compelling story comes full circle, beginning and ending with the same rule, Rule 11. During the late sixties to the early eighties, twelve, an alarming amount…show more content…
In the beginning of the story Schlichtmann is an arrogant, self confident, a top ten most eligible bachelor dressed in expensive Dmitri suits and silk ties, driving around quickly in a black Porsche. There is no doubt about it that Schlichtmann took the case for money and fame. He let the Woburn case rot like an orphan in his firm’s files for three years until he found the “deep pockets” to sue. He directly contradicted himself when taking this case because one of his initial reasons for not taking it was the cost. When asked why he took the case, Schlichtmann responded, “pride, greed, ambition. Getting rich by doing good (491).”Greed was his motivating factor but Schlichtmann quickly learned that being rich isn’t so difficult, being famous isn’t so difficult, being rich and famous together aren’t so difficult, but being rich, famous and doing good together was very difficult. 2.2 million dollars later and his residence as homeless, Schlichtmann surely let greed blind him. It is hard to say whether Schlichtmann persevered with the case because of a change of heart, or because the mere fact that he had invested almost a decade of his life to it. However I do feel competent in saying that after receiving the verdict against Beatrice and despite being broke, Schlichtmann persevered because he cared about this case.…show more content…
The transformation of Schlichtmann is the perfect example of this. The opening scene of the movie shows a car accident and Schlichtmann handing his card to one of the victims. He then pushes a male into the courtroom in a wheelchair and toasts his victory with champagne afterwards. Schlichtmann is living the fast, glamorous life. Yet one of the major problems in the film is the way his change of heart is displayed. In many scenes of the film, Schlichtmann is seen overlooking the polluted areas in question and is portrayed as having an inner moral transformation. The movie portrays him more of a hero than a greedy personal injury

More about Review Of Jonathan Harr's A Civil Action

Open Document