There is no proof that this story has any truth. There is something no one has considered, the danger to our own soldiers when they are captured. Here again I quote: “Worse, you'll have the other side effects of torture. It "endangers our soldiers on the battlefield by encouraging reciprocity." It does "damage to our country's image" and undermines our credibility in Iraq.” (Applebaum) It undermines the work of our soldiers that are helping make Iraq into a country ruled by its people instead of a dictator.
In fact, when questioned about the names of his flight squadron members, and he gave the Vietnamese names of the offensive line of the Green Bay Packers (423). The torturers can be easily fooled because they cannot reliably verify the accuracy of the information they get from a torture victim. Therefore, the problem of unreliable intelligence deals a big blow against torture. Many nations, including the United States, made torturing illegal, but if America tortures a soldier from other nations, they can do the same back to America (424). If American troops held another nation’s soldier captive, the enemy may feel they have the right to do the same.
This is very detailed and horrific because he is saying he won’t be able to stop his soldiers from raping the women in the city. Henry’s choice of words in this speech show us that not only can Henry influence people into fighting but he can create the illusion that disturbing things will happen if you don’t do what I say. This actually isn’t the best type of leadership because he his leading with fear. It is an effective form of leadership but it is one that doesn’t always work
Write down the TWO most important things he says about the writing of history. The two most important things he says about the writing of history are: * He said that we must not accept the memory of states as our own. The history of any country conceals violent conflicts of interest between conquerors and conquered, masters and slaves, capitalists and workers. * But to think that history-writing must intent simply to repeat the failures that control the past is to make historians traitors in an endless cycle of conquest. 1.
In my opinion Operation Rolling Thunder (ORT) was a massive failure. As the US did not meet its official aims and objectives of stopping the spread of communism to Vietnam. It caused a lot of inexperienced soldiers to lose their lives. Also having a major effect on America its self as the country battled to juggle money to afford the cost of the war. But one of the hardest battle’s for the US was to keep their own countries support.
Some would argue that by killing our enemies without due process, that we are no worse than our enemies in our barbarism. While such a statement is targeted at an audience's pathos, and is devoid of substance, it nevertheless points to the slippery sloped involved in targeted extra-judicial killing. Once powers contravening the Constitution have been put into the hands of government, this power is not easily removed. With this, in dealing with the dangers of terrorism, at home and abroad, America's policies do threaten its democracy. With this, it is of the utmost imperative that independent reviews of governmental policy, regardless of secrecy and classification, take place so as to ensure that extra-judicial governmental actions fall within the national interest, rather the whims of a given
The use of force is not necessary to gain the cooperation of sources, as prisoners are more likely to cooperate when they feel a sense of trust and respect. Using torture as a means of reducing local threats has proven not to work. Knowing that they will be subject to humiliation and physical abuse makes insurgents fight harder to avoid capture and has increased their dislike for American Forces. It can result in retaliatory acts against our own
Understanding the moral concept of torture being wrong but in this case the use of torture used to terrorist attacks on innocent people. A fine line when discussing what is right and wrong however executed in the proper way should be accepted. When identifying torture by no means should it be physical pain that’s involved. Mental torture has been used and considered illegal to obtain information, but most of the time used without a second glance. If McCain even agrees with the simple fact how Al Qaeda expresses the word “sociopath” in relation to the meaning of terrorists acts, it applies to them (Page698).
Justification for “The Case for Torture” Torture is unacceptable in every society and most will agree, but is it inexcusable? Depending on how you look at it, there may be situations in which it could possibly be a necessary evil. With the amount of lives lost on a daily basis due to the crimes of passion, of religion, and in today’s world, those of war. Could some of these lives have been saved if the information had been extracted in time? Maybe.
Some people may argue that killing during war is a sin because many people end up losing their lives, on the other hand others may say that killing during war should not count as a sin because the soldiers are risking their lives to protect their land and the innocent people who live there. Although most people say that it shouldn’t count as a sin because when soldiers fight during war, they are protecting their land and the innocent people that accommodate it. They also have orders from the military leader that they cannot disobey. It is also mentioned in the Bible and the Quran that people must protect their country and others who live there. Killing people during war time should not count as a sin for many reasons.