Is Elroy Berdahl a Good Person

1244 Words5 Pages
Is Elroy Berdahl a Good Person? In The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien one character that sticks out as good person is Elroy Berdahl. Elroy Berdahl comes up in the story/chapter titled "On the Rainy River" in which Tim O'Brien goes up to the Tip Top Lodge, on the border of the United States and Canada, where Elroy Berdahl lives and works. Tim O'Brien runs away to the Tip Top Lodge to escape from a war that he has no desire to fight in. Even though the book never specifically specifies that Elroy Berdahl knows why Tim O'Brien has come to his lodge, it is evident to the reader that Elroy is a sharp and intelligent man and realizes that O'Brien is a young man trying to make a decision that will affect him the rest of his life. Elroy realized that O'Brien was contemplating deserting his country and running to Canada and that whatever direction he chose to head in it must be his decision. This quality of Elroy's, his ability to give O'Brien the right to make his decision for himself, makes him a good person. Ultimately being a good person is decided by one's actions. One action that Elroy Berdahl takes in the story "On the Rainy River" is when he takes Tim O'Brien out on his boat to cross the river into Canada. Tim O'Brien has no idea that Elroy Berdahl knows why he is taking him to Canada but it is evident to the reader that Elroy is wise old man and that he knows that Tim O'Brien is a lost young man trying to find his way in the world. Elroy knows that O'Brien is making possibly one of the biggest decisions of his life but that it is not his place to advise or influence O'Brien in his decision but rather support him in whatever direction he chooses to head in. O'Brien describes Elroy's guidance by saying, "It struck me then that he must've planned it. I'll never be certain, of course, but I think he meant to bring me up against the realities, to guide me across

More about Is Elroy Berdahl a Good Person

Open Document