Information Is Torture Research Paper

1897 Words8 Pages
Information is Torture Giovanni R Celestial SOC 120 Intro to Ethics Prof. Steven Smith February 3, 2013 Information is Torture War has been a tragic realization throughout history and will continue to be in the foreseen future. It is a time that breaks down our understanding of humanity down to the core and in many cases leaves us with more questions than answers. It is also a time that is undoubtedly filled with extreme acts that leave us baffled as to what is right and what is wrong. Our understanding of ethics and morality suddenly become compromised, bringing us to the harsh fact that the subject is nowhere near as clear cut as we try to make it seem with our multiple philosophical theories. We then realize there are a lot…show more content…
More often times than not, as you begin to put them together, they lead to more pieces of the puzzle that end up painting an enormous and complex picture. Look how long it took us to find Bin Laden, the most wanted man and number one enemy of the United States. Believe it or not, torture and harsh interrogation tactics is what eventually led our Forces to his location. USA Today (2011) tells us, “It's clear that torture played some role in piecing together the chain of information that led to bin Laden's lair in Pakistan. CIA Director Leon Panetta acknowledged as much’ (If torture led us, para. 6). Our interrogation techniques were instrumental in the capture of Bin Laden and giving our whole Nation what they wanted. Before the attacks of 9/11 we already had forces in the Middle East to create an insurgency against the Taliban and al-Qaeda; Perhaps if we used “harsh interrogation” techniques prior to 9/11, the attacks could have been diverted and the war might have never even took off. The thousands of lives lost from all countries involved as a result from the attacks and the war would still be here today. The global economic hardships being faced as a result of the strain from years of conflict might cease to…show more content…
I feel that although the need to torture to obtain information is a hard pill to swallow, it is crucial to success and preserve life. On a national level, it seems that most share the same approach. “The forum followed a poll released last month that states 63 percent of Americans believe that torture of terrorist suspects is justified in certain situations” (Meehan, 2005, para. 3). I’m sure that most of us can agree that we want an end to the war on terrorism and that we want to preserve as much life as possible. That being said, Mosser (2010) says that ethical egoism is, “Simply put, I know what I want, and something is good, or right, if it helps me to obtain that desire (and bad, or wrong, if it interferes with my doing so). If doing something promotes my own happiness or helps me reach my desired goals, I should do it. That is the fundamental principle of ethical egoism” (“What is Ethical Egoism,” para.
Open Document