Immigration In The United States

2087 Words9 Pages
Founded on immigrants the United States is proud of her extremely diverse population. However, is it time for the United States to consider closing her borders to immigrants – legal and illegal for the greater good. Is the very thing that made this country strong going to be her demise! Immigrants legal or illegal entering the United States daily are causing several important concerns in areas like national security and financial hardships. Strong arguments exist on both sides when immigration laws are on the table surrounding their influence on terrorism, health care, economics, and employment. Terrorism Terrorism as seen on September 11th, 2001 within the borders of the United States shook the country to its core. People began to question…show more content…
Because hospitals must provide free health care and immigrants mostly cluster in specific areas the costs are not evenly distributed. Therefore, the data does not accurately represent the cost of provision of health care for illegal immigrants only, but rather considers the cost of providing health care for every uninsured person. Whereas emergency room costs are higher for foreign born children than children born in the United States, it is lower for foreign born adults than it is for adults born in the United States. In fact in the under 65 age group the value of health care services used ranged from 30-75% lower for persons born in the United States than for immigrants. The Udall study also concluded that by 2003, of the uninsured figure of 5.1 million, 3.6 were born in the United States, the remaining 1.3 are immigrants making the United States born uninsured constitute the larger proportion of uninsured persons in the country. It should also be noted that of this 1.3 million immigrants, there is no differentiation between legal immigrants and illegal immigrants. Therefore, further reduction the percentage of illegal immigrants presenting a drain on the economy via uncompensated health…show more content…
There are several concerns associated with this practice, especially when some of these workers are in the United States illegally. This labor’s positive and negative impact on the United States’ agriculture warrants further exploration and if to consider conditional legalization. Pros to Current Closed Border Policy Every illegal worker hired by a farmer takes a job from a citizen or legal resident. This practice helps keep the unemployed out of work and takes revenue from local coffers. Farmers can help stimulate the local economy with little effect on product availability by hiring only legal workers. There are moral and ethical implications to this illegal practice as well. Illegal workers technically do not exist. Therefore, established labor laws that protect American workers do not apply. The sometimes poor conditions and low wages exploit illegal workers and propagate the negative correlation between illegal aliens and agriculture. This would be nonexistent if current immigration laws were stringently enforced. The benefit of hiring illegal workers often overshadows the negative correlation highlighted earlier. Cons to Current Closed Border
Open Document