Example of Critical Analysis

435 Words2 Pages
Critical Analysis In the article We Send Too Many Students to College by Marty Nemko, Marty Nemko discusses how it is possible to be successful and not have gone to college. He continues in his argument by discussing other reasonable alternatives to college and gives examples of successful people that did not continue with their education. Although in good taste, Nemko is wrong to suggest that options such as apprenticeships and “short career-preparation programs at community colleges” are available to all those who cannot handle the college life, for many Americans there are only two options, the school house or the jail house. Nemko lists several influential persons in the country that have been successful without the aid of a formal college education. In this list he includes great politicians, entrepreneurs, and even some entertainers. Yes, it is possible to be successful and not have received a bachelors or other degree. However Nemko doesn’t give practical examples of people who have been successful. For example, Bill Gates, one the most successful people in the world, is a college drop out. Mr. Gates is a terrible because of where he came from. He was from an upper middle class family his father was a lawyer, his mother served on the board of directors for First Interstate Bancsystem, and his grandfather was a national bank president. Now from knowing all of that about his life, how many of college students can say they have a great heritage to fall back on like Bill Gates? Mark Zuckerberg, the founder of Facebook, was a prodigy as a child who excelled in every aspect of his secondary education but it was not until He had started his second at Harvard developed the idea for Facebook. First generations college students, specifically those of non-European heritage, do not have such enormous shoulders to stand on. College kids come from varied background which
Open Document