A third problem with the Constitution according to the Anti-Federalist was that the states would have no power. The first issue the Anti-Federalists were concerned with was the national government having too much power. In the Anti-Federalist Paper No. 11 they address this issue about unrestricted power over commerce should not be given to the national government. The Anti-Federalists were worried that if a national government was in charge of commerce, then the states will not all get what they need and will begin to fail.
Mostly the Anti-Federalists thought that the Constitution created too strong of a central government. They felt that the Constitution did not create a Federal government, but a single national government. They were afraid that the power of the states would be lost and that the people would lose their individual rights because a few individuals would take over. As a result, they proposed The Bill of Rights, to make sure the citizens were protected by the law. They believed that no Bill of Rights would be equal to no check on our
They believed that each state should have a self governed, and independent. Anti-Federalists also argued that there was no bill of rights, and the Congress and executive branch held too much power. But mostly the lack of a bill of rights was the focus of the Anti-Federalist against ratifying the Constitution. But Federalists on the other hand favored the creation of a strong federal government that would more closely unite the states as one large, continental nation of a strong federal government that would more closely unite the states as one large, continental nation. The Federalists like the separation of powers into three independent branches protected the rights of the people.
51, therefore government is necessary to control its people but with the limit power so that there will be no self-interested ambitions held by government. With the separation of powers, each branch will have way to limit the power of other branches. For example, “Congress is given the chief lawmaking power under the Constitution, but a bill can become a law only if the president signs it. The Supreme Court has the power to reject a law formulated by Congress and signed by the president if it is contrary to the Constitution” (Edward S. Greenberg). With this way, the self-interest ambition of one branch will counter the ambition of other branches just like James Madison wrote in federalist no.
At the Constitutional Convention the Federalists drew up plans for a new constitution while the Anti-Federalists complained and picked apart their plan, even though the Anti-Federalists had no plan of their own. The main issue the Anti-Federalists had with the new constitution was that they thought that it would not protect the rights of states and individuals. Federalists argued that a stronger government was necessary, not to impede individual rights, but to be able to pass and enforce laws. Federalists also argued a stronger bond between states was needed to improve the economic state of the country. Under the Articles of Confederation each state printed their own currency which became worthless in any other
When he proposed the creation of the national debt the anti-federalist protested against this idea because in the Constitution it never stated anything about a bank. Hamilton believed that the Constitution should be interpreted loosely and do anything that was necessary and proper. Lastly he believed that the government should be run by the educated and wealthy not the common people. Thomas Jefferson is known as the author of the Declaration of Independence and leader of the Anti-Federalists. His political views were opposite of Hamilton’s.
They stressed that the newly created form of central government did not threaten the states’ rights. The Anti-Federalists touted the “spirit of ‘76” (Schultz, page 15) in favor of a weaker central government, preservation of states’ rights, strong individual liberties and at the very least a robust bill of rights to protect individual liberties. Ratification stalled as Anti-Federalists from larger states such as Massachusetts, New York and Virginia refused to ratify until a bill of rights for citizens was guaranteed, and Federalists, eager to see the Constitution enacted, resisted lengthy amendments to the Constitution for fear of having to begin writing the entire framework over
The effect was to ignore a law he is bound to enforce and simple not enforce it. Kings and monarchs engage in this behavior. They rule by edict. The president is not acting like the president; he is acting like a king. If he can simply ignore laws he doesn’t want to enforce for whatever reason, what keeps him from simply doing what he wants and ignoring the congress of the United States?
Democracy Gone Wrong Democracy can be defined as a system of government by a whole population or all eligible members of a state typically through elected representatives, where as republic can be defined as a state in which supreme power is held by people and their elected representatives and which has an elected or nominated president. Although the founding fathers did not work within a democratic framework the only way the Constitution would pass was because it had to be democratic. The Constitution was made to form a stronger central government, but they didn’t want to represent the common peoples, and did not constitute individual rights. In forming a strong central government, the people wanted to revise the Articles of Confederation
In the author's opinion, this debate, from a federal standpoint, is totally flawed because it is the system of government established by the Constitution that is the key to resolving this controversy not the intent and wording of the Second Amendment. The Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, one of the groups opposed to the private ownership of firearms, claims the right enumerated in the Second Amendment pertains to the State militias. On their website, this organization claims the Second Amendment was adopted "to prevent the federal government from disarming the State militias." The U.S.