Cold Mountain Essay

1501 Words7 Pages
The difference between the Cold Mountain novel and movie Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier is a love story set during the time of the civil war. The Cold Mountain movie version is the same story as the novel but gives the added pleasure of watching it on television. The Cold Mountain movie version and novel have many differences that affect the feel of the story. One difference between the novel and movie that shifts the feel of the story from mournful to anger is how the character Birch is portrayed. The feel of the story has a mournful feel when Birch is mentioned in the novel. He is a member of Teague’s Home Guard group that is depicted in the novel as a boy with a good heart that is coming to realize the horrors of war. The boy does not want to be a part of the killing that occurs within the group, but knows he cannot leave them or else he might be look like a traitor. He feels remorse for those who are killed, and wishes he does not have to do any killing of his own. The feel of the story in the novel is really affected when Birch shoots Inman in the end and cannot believe what he has done. After Birch shoots Inman he looks down at his pistol and says, “They God.” It seems he had never shot a weapon before. It has a very mournful affect to the feel of the story. The feel of story is affected from how Birch is portrayed in the novel to how he is portrayed in the movie. The feel changes from a mournful feel to an angrier feel when Birch is mentioned in the movie. Birch is portrayed in the movie as a boy who is mean, ruthless, and has no heart. He wants to kill and does it more out of passion than out of duty. The anger begins when Birch is Torturing Mrs. Swanger by stepping on the wood and smashing her fingers. He then ends up shooting her two sons as they come running across the field for their mom. The anger continues every time Birch is mentioned until the
Open Document