Constitution. The S.B. 1070 disrupts the priorities and resources of federal enforcement that focus on aliens who pose a threat to national security or public safety. They also claim that the federal government has preeminent authority to regulate immigration matters and that the enforcement of the Arizona law is counterproductive to the national immigration policy and it will cause detention and harassment of authorized visitors, immigrants, and citizens who do not carry their identification documents. S.B.1070 will certainly interfere in essential foreign policy and national security interests by disrupting the United States' relationship with Mexico and other
This is “the practice by law enforcement of considering race as an indicator of the likelihood of criminal behavior” (Robinson 530). The issue of using race to identify people is disputable because minorities feel that it is an act of inequality and also humiliating. However, the Supreme Court supports its legality as long as ethnicity is seen as an important factor that determines the detainment of an individual. Therefore, there are many pros and cons about the legality of this law enforcement technique. During times of war, racial
The problems caused by the Patriot Act are affecting ordinary civilian, especially legal immigrants. This law authorizes of indefinite detentions of immigrants; law enforcement officers search a home or business without the owner’s or the occupant’s permission or knowledge; allows the FBI to search telephone, e-mail, and financial records without a court order. Most of the Act only affects to the immigrants. Martin Luther King Jr. writes, “An unjust law is a code that a majority inflicts on a minority that is not binding on itself” (par. 15).
Border Patrol agents not only use their authority and racial profiling at checkpoints, they have gone as far as raiding Latino communities and workplaces to find illegal immigrants. In this situation, the Latino workers were the target and are on a continuous basis. “These policies have unjustly expanded the purview of and undermined basic trust in local law enforcement, alienated immigrant communities, and created an atmosphere of fear anti-immigrant rhetoric has led to a dramatic increase in hate crimes against and racial profiling of Latinos” (aclu, 2012). A more relative example of profiling is what the governor of Arizona signed into law in April 2010. “On April 23, 2010, Arizona governor Jan Brewer signed into law a discriminatory and un-American law that will require police officers in Arizona to ask people for their papers based only on some undefined "reasonable suspicion" that they are in the country unlawfully.
Many of the provisions in the two laws are similar. For example, both laws state that upon an arrest or traffic stop, law enforcement must make a reasonable attempt to determine the person’s citizenship and immigration status. Both laws also state that law enforcement may not consider race, color or origin in enforcement of this law. Both laws state that lawful presence may be presumed if the suspect can present a state-issued photo ID, state or federal issued ID, or passport. In Arizona, A person is guilty of trespassing if he is present on any public or private land in the state and does not have his or her Alien Registration card or has failed to register.
Changing the Security along the U.S and Mexico Border There is no other place in the world where an invisible line draws such a disparity in wealth and lifestyle. There are Mexican refuges that want to come to America for a better life for themselves and their families. There is no easy answer to fix this issue. The Department of Homeland Security was created in response to the Sept. 11th attacks. Their mission is to prevent illegal aliens from entering that cause a threat to American society.
The U.S. should not grant amnesty to illegal incomers’. No matter what the penalties are, any program that grants individuals who are unlawfully present the legal permission to remain here rewards illegal behavior. How possible do you think it is to deport immigrants? It’s very easy, and the formula is: go to where you know immigrants, arrest them and then deport them. Do you realize that those who enter the U.S. should not be rewarded with permanent legal status or such
As directly stated with complete evidence from an attorney, these contradictions are not only unjust but go against Arizona at the federal court level. Publisher Amir Efrati, of The Wall Street Journal states, “The states have no power to pass immigration laws because it is an attribute of foreign affairs. Just as a state cannot have their own foreign policies and immigration laws either” (Efrati). Also, Stephanie Condon posts how Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham stated, “ Arizona's new immigration law is unconstitutional and that "it doesn't represent the best way forward" when it comes to addressing illegal immigration” (Condon). In simple terms, if this law is not repealed Arizona will be going against the constitution, the 14th amendment is used unjustly, and bigger problems will
What is illegal immigration you ask? Well it is when an unauthorized or undocumented alien from another country crosses the national border in a way that violates the immigration laws of this country. In today’s world we are faced with the problems of illegal immigration, what we don’t know is that this actually cost us money. As of today we have eleven million illegal aliens in our United States, some of these 6,640,000 are from just Mexico alone. Mexico is one of our big illegal immigration problems we are faced with.
They steal jobs and depress the wages, and this is especially mentioned in the media nowadays when 9 % of the Americans are unemployed. And often when something bad happens, like the unemployment and bad economy, people like to blame someone, and in this particular case, the Hispanic immigrants are the ones to get blamed. To counteract this whole thing, the state of Arizona has now made a new law concerning illegal immigration. Before the law, illegal immigration was a federal crime, so therefore only the Federal Bureau of Investigation took action in these cases. But now, Arizona has announced that, with this new law, any police officer or sheriff has the right to stop any person who looks “suspicious”.